- Rachael Thomas

- Aug 1
- 3 min read

“Elbows up.”
That was Prime Minister Mark Carney’s message to Canadians. It was meant to project strength against Washington and reassure the country that he could handle President Donald Trump.
Canadians should judge that promise with the answer to one simple question: has the Prime Minister’s approach actually made Canada stronger?
Since Carney took office, tariffs have escalated, negotiations remain unresolved, businesses are holding back investment, and a recent KPMG survey reveals that 42 per cent of Canadian manufacturing companies have either already moved production to the United States or are considering doing so.
Instead of putting forward a strategy that delivers results, the Liberals have repeatedly caved. Carney’s elbows are supposedly up, but the results are discouraging. His approach is doing more harm than good, and the consequences are hitting close to home—especially in Lethbridge.
Lethbridge has far more at stake than most. In 2023, businesses in our region exported more than $2 billion worth of goods to the United States, accounting for a staggering 91.7 per cent of all local merchandise exports and nearly one-fifth of our total regional GDP. It is no surprise the Canadian Chamber of Commerce ranked Lethbridge 10th out of 41 Canadian cities for vulnerability to U.S. tariffs.
These figures are not abstract. They represent family farms, processing plants, and manufacturers across southern Alberta, alongside hardworking people whose paycheques depend on reliable access to our largest customer. The United States is not just another market for us; it buys our beef, canola, potatoes, and manufactured goods. When that access becomes uncertain, the shockwaves hit farm gates, factory floors, and family budgets directly.
President Trump’s tariffs belong to his administration, but Canadians rightly expect their government to prepare for foreseeable risks and defend our national interests.
A strong government would make restoring free trade with the United States its top priority. Yet, under the Carney Liberals, tariffs have worsened, and major concessions have been handed out for nothing in return. Recently, the government agreed to hand over half of the Gordie Howe International Bridge’s net revenues to a U.S.-controlled fund for its first 15 years—surrendering revenue from a bridge Canada fully financed.
To make matters worse, the Bank of Canada warns that persistent trade uncertainty has left business investment flat as companies indefinitely freeze expansions and equipment purchases.
Real strength does not mean picking fights for political applause. It means knowing what Canada needs, defending it tactfully, and securing results. Canada must restore stable, tariff-free access to the United States and give businesses the certainty to invest. That is impossible if Carney continues to needlessly antagonize President Trump, as he has done on multiple occasions, including during his speech at Davos.
Serious economic challenges require serious negotiation, not theatrics.
While economic diversification is a vital long-term goal, it cannot become an excuse to neglect the customer buying nearly 92 per cent of Lethbridge’s exports today. New markets cannot replace American demand overnight, nor can the necessary infrastructure be built quickly enough to protect producers facing tariffs right now.
A responsible government treats our relationship with our largest customer as an economic necessity. Tough talk may generate headlines, but it doesn’t move trucks across the border. Canada’s trade policy must be grounded in the livelihoods at stake—especially in communities like Lethbridge.
When a Prime Minister raises his elbows without a plan, it's everyday Canadians who take the hit.



